As soon as the project planning begins, one or two members of the team begin to ask questions that you believe were answered during the kickoff meeting. One person begins to question the scope of the project and the mission derived from the scope. This is where the PM has to spend valuable time, once again, to discuss the scope and the mission. This interruption to the normal flow of the project happens often in your projects. Is it the way you communicate? Are you too quick and skip the details that some members consider important?
Now, before you lose all confidence in yourself, you have to review your communication skills. If you find that you do have to improve your communication skills, I suggest Toastmasters International as an excellent non-profit organization that I have been involved with for almost 20 years.
However, it may be that some members of your team are habitually disruptive and argumentative by nature. You may have users that are part of the project team that were not part of scoping the project and do not feel that they are not part of the team nor that the project is a positive effect on their daily work. What can you do as PM when faced with these problems?
Dealing with the Disruptive Team Member
Every PM or line manager has had to deal with a disruptive employee. A line manager has Human Resource tools at their discretion to deal directly with a disruptive employee. A PM does not have the same tools that a line manager has, but must deal directly with the disruptive team member. For a PM, this is a tightrope that must be walked very carefully. Here are some steps that a PM can take:
· Speak directly to the disruptive member. Confrontation is not something that most people look forward to. However, we have all had a run-in with the individual who seems to argue for argument’s sake. A PM must confront this person before other members begin to become disillusioned with the PM leading the project. Appeal to the member’s sense of team unity and mission objectives.
Do not reject this suggestion out of hand. If the PM has conducted the kickoff properly, the PM should discuss the benefits of the project, the uniqueness of being selected for the team, and the need for unity and team work. These points should be important factors to the member. Being part of this project can benefit the member’s career. These should be the topics that the PM should bring up and hopefully influence the member to rethink their approach to the project and to other team members.
· Speak to the disruptive member’s manager. This has to be done gingerly as not to make the manager feel you are overstepping your bounds. First, you must inform your manager of your decision to meet with this manager about a problem employee. Next, you must ensure that you are prepared with details regarding your attempts to give the disruptive member every opportunity to change their disruptive ways and what your expectations are from the meeting with the members’ manager. If the member is still needed on the project, the objective is to convince the manager that he/she speak to the member to consider a different approach to the project. If the member’s actions are considered more disruptive than the member’s contributions are needed, then the PM must request that the manager remove the member from the team.
· Demand that the member leave the project team. The last step is to remove the disruptive member from the project. Removing a resource is the last thing a PM wants to do, considering how difficult it is to replace a resource. However, it all the steps you have taken have not worked, the PM does not have a choice. Throughout this process, the PM must be taking notes and make sure that all interactions are documented for any HR needs.
In all of this, the PM must keep his/her composure to ensure that he/she is viewed as the manager who wants to keep the project moving forward. The risk is that the resource may make this personal. The PM must keep above this type of discussion. In the end, the project will fare better without this resource. The PM must keep the good of the project and the rest of the project team in mind to ensure success.I am open to discussion at any time on these blogs or anything else related to project management you would like to explore. If you would like to comment about this blog, please do so by posting on this blog or by responding in an email at Benny A. Recine.You may inspire a blog article. I look forward to your comments.